Bong, joint or vaporizer: which is least harmful? What do studies say

Is vaporization less harmful than smoking? Bong, joint, pipe, and vaporizer in a research table: carbon monoxide, tar, lungs, cancer, and what is still unknown.

Is vaporization less harmful than smoking? The strongest measurement on humans comes from a small hospital study. Eighteen healthy volunteers received cannabis from a vaporizer or in a cigarette. The THC concentration in the blood was similar, and carbon monoxide in exhaled air was lower after vaporization (Abrams et al., Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics, 2007). Regarding the question of bong or joint, the data is much weaker than forums suggest. This text compares a joint, blunt, bong, pipe, and vaporizer based on what has actually been measured. For each method, we also note what the studies did not cover. The table in the second part of the text shows in one place what is least harmful according to available data and how strong that data is.

KEY INFORMATION
• Vaporization resulted in similar THC levels in the blood with lower carbon monoxide than smoking (Abrams et al., 2007, 18 people).
• In the only test of water pipes we found, the bong performed worse than the joint; the study was not peer-reviewed.
• Blunt increases carbon monoxide, and tobacco in the joint is associated with nicotine dependence.
• Studies on lung cancer yield results in both directions.

What is the difference between combustion and vaporization?

Combustion creates new compounds, while vaporization primarily evaporates those already present in the herb. In a vaporizer test with the Volcano, the vapor consisted almost exclusively of cannabinoids, with traces of three other compounds. The smoke contained over 111 compounds, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) (Gieringer et al., Journal of Cannabis Therapeutics, 2004). The study covered only this one device.

Cannabis smoke is not a milder version of tobacco smoke; it has a different composition. In a measurement with a smoking machine, it contained up to 20 times more ammonia and 3-5 times more, among others, hydrogen cyanide than tobacco smoke, but less PAHs in inhaled smoke (Moir et al., Chemical Research in Toxicology, 2008).

Temperature also matters. In a laboratory comparison, vapor from the Volcano at 200 and 230 °C had a significantly higher cannabinoid content relative to by-products than smoke from a joint (Pomahacova et al., Inhalation Toxicology, 2009). The study provides a ratio, not the quantity of these products. How to set the temperature is described in the guide vaporization temperature: what to set and why.

The name of the device does not guarantee the absence of combustion. In a test of five vaporizers, a gas model without temperature control left ash and visible smoke (Lanz et al., PLOS ONE, 2016). In this test, the difference was made by temperature control, not the label on the box.

How much carbon monoxide do joints, blunts, and vaporizers produce?

Blunts produce more carbon monoxide than joints, joints significantly more than tobacco cigarettes, and vaporizers less than a cannabis cigarette; however, numbers from different studies should not be compared. Measurements were found for these three methods. In a 1988 study (15 men), a cannabis joint compared to a cigarette of similar weight produced about five times the increase in carboxyhemoglobin, which is hemoglobin bound to carbon monoxide. It also produced about three times more inhaled tar (Wu et al., New England Journal of Medicine, 1988).

Researchers also measured the smoking method. Participants took two-thirds larger puffs and inhaled one-third deeper. They held their breath four times longer. The result pertains to the entire joint versus the entire cigarette under those conditions. It does not yield a simple conversion factor for joints to cigarettes.

A blunt, which is a joint in a cigar leaf, raises carbon monoxide more than a joint. In a controlled study (24 people), it produced higher carbon monoxide in exhaled air than a joint in paper with the same amount of cannabis (Cooper and Haney, Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 2009).

For the vaporizer, the measurement is favorable. Eighteen volunteers received herb of three strengths, from 1.7% to 6.8% THC, from the Volcano vaporizer or in a cigarette over six days in the hospital. The THC concentration in the blood was similar, and carbon monoxide after vaporization was lower (Abrams et al., 2007). The authors called it a pilot study: it shows the difference in exposure but not long-term effects. We did not find carbon monoxide measurements for bongs and pipes.

Bong or joint: does the water in the bong filter the smoke?

The only study we found does not confirm that water filters smoke. In a 1996 test (California NORML and MAPS, smoking machine, raw material about 2.3% THC), all water pipes performed worse than a regular unfiltered joint. The bong produced 30% more tar per unit of cannabinoids (Gieringer, MAPS Bulletin, 1996).

This result has serious limitations. It is a text from a bulletin, not a peer-reviewed paper, and the laboratory was not named. The measure was relative: tar per unit of cannabinoids, not the actual amount of tar. Gases, including carbon monoxide, were not measured. The author himself cautioned that water may retain other toxins beyond solid particles and that it is too early to draw conclusions about the harm of water pipes from this test. Therefore, the data does not indicate that a bong is more harmful than a joint.

Several popular claims about bongs were not found in studies. These include that water does not retain carbon monoxide at all, that cooler smoke is inhaled deeper, and that water in the chamber promotes microorganisms. They may be true, but for now, they are reasoning, not measurement results. We also did not find a peer-reviewed study of bongs with carbon monoxide measurement.

What does tobacco added to a joint change?

First of all, it adds nicotine. In a Canadian cohort (788 young adults), those who added tobacco to cannabis, especially weekly or daily, met more nicotine dependence criteria. This was also true after accounting for cigarettes (Dugas et al., Addictive Behaviors, 2022). This is a correlation, not proof of causation.

In Europe, this is a common practice. In a global survey (33,687 people from 18 countries), in European countries, 77% to 91% of users mixed cannabis with tobacco, while in the USA, 4.4% (Hindocha et al., Frontiers in Psychiatry, 2016). Poland was not included in this survey. People who used cannabis without tobacco were more likely to want to reduce cigarette smoking.

Where does this popularity come from? One explanation comes from the laboratory. In a 2009 test, the addition of tobacco increased the efficiency of THC release from cannabis by up to 45% (Van der Kooy et al., Inhalation Toxicology, 2009). This is a result from apparatus, not from human studies. It explains why the mixture has been adopted, but it is not a benefit: along with THC comes nicotine.

A review by Meier and Hatsukami (Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 2016) notes that blunt smokers usually have higher carbon monoxide in exhaled air. Cannabis smoke may also contain more of certain carcinogenic substances than tobacco smoke. A systematic review of 45 studies linked combining both substances with lower risk assessment and dependence on them, mainly based on observational studies (Schauer et al., Addictive Behaviors, 2017).

Does a pipe or a bowl harm less than a joint?

We did not find studies that measured smoke from a pipe or bowl separately. In large cohort studies, a pipe was counted the same as a joint. The CARDIA study (5,115 people, 20 years) considered one joint or one packed pipe as the same unit (Pletcher et al., JAMA, 2012). The Dunedin cohort did not distinguish between a joint and a bong (Hancox et al., 2010).

A pipe and bowl burn the herb just like a joint, only without paper. A bowl is a small pipe for one small portion. A smaller portion means less smoke in one session, but this is a conclusion from quantity, not measurement results. We did not find a measurement showing whether smoke from a pipe has a different composition than smoke from a joint.

Authors of a large online survey listed pipes alongside joints, blunts, and water pipes as methods where switching to a vaporizer could reduce respiratory symptoms (Earleywine and Barnwell, Harm Reduction Journal, 2007). Thus, the pipe was placed in the same group as the joint and bong. This is a conclusion from correlations in self-reports, not a measurement of smoke from a pipe.

How does smoking cannabis affect the lungs in long-term studies?

Regular smoking is associated with bronchial symptoms, but in most studies, not with a decline in lung function typical of tobacco. According to a meta-analysis of 22 studies, low-quality evidence suggests a link between cannabis smoking and cough, sputum production, and wheezing (Ghasemiesfe et al., Annals of Internal Medicine, 2018).

In the New Zealand Dunedin cohort, smoking at least 52 times a year was associated with morning cough and sputum production. Reducing smoking often resulted in symptom relief (Hancox et al., European Respiratory Journal, 2015). At age 32, the same group had greater lung volume and greater airway resistance. However, there was no decline in FEV1, which is the volume exhaled in the first second, typical of tobacco (Hancox et al., 2010).

The American CARDIA study tracked 5,115 adults for 20 years. Occasional and low total cannabis smoking was not associated with worse lung function. However, data for very heavy smoking were too sparse to rule out harm (Pletcher et al., JAMA, 2012).

Newer data from Dunedin raise more concerns. At age 45, long-term cannabis smoking was associated with worse gas exchange in the lungs (Hancox et al., American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 2022). Tashkin’s review (Annals of the American Thoracic Society, 2013) states that regular cannabis smoking causes visible and microscopic damage to large airways. A clear link to chronic obstructive pulmonary disease has not been demonstrated, and the risk of pulmonary complications is, according to the author, significantly lower than with tobacco. This is a lower risk, not an absence of risk.

Does smoking cannabis increase the risk of lung cancer?

The evidence goes both ways, and the matter is not settled. The largest case-control studies found no clear link between cannabis smoking and lung cancer. A study from Los Angeles included 1,212 patients with lung cancer or cancer of the upper aerodigestive tract and 1,040 people from the control group (Hashibe et al., Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers and Prevention, 2006). The authors allowed for selection bias.

A meta-analysis of six studies (2,159 patients, 2,985 people in control groups) also found little evidence of increased risk among habitual or long-term cannabis smokers (Zhang et al., International Journal of Cancer, 2015). The risks associated with very heavy smoking were not ruled out by this work.

A smaller study from New Zealand (79 patients under 55 years old, 324 people in the control group) indicated an 8% increase in risk for each year-joint, meaning one year of smoking one joint daily (Aldington et al., European Respiratory Journal, 2008). The authors concluded that long-term cannabis smoking increases the risk of lung cancer in young adults.

Tashkin’s review (2013) presents this cautiously. The results do not suggest higher risk with light or moderate smoking, while the results for heavy and long-term smoking are mixed. Current data do not therefore resolve whether cannabis smoking increases the risk of lung cancer.

Is vaporization less harmful than smoking?

For the respiratory system, probably yes, but the evidence is short and sparse. In a survey of 6,883 users, 152 people who primarily vaporized had about a 60% lower chance of reporting respiratory symptoms (OR 0.40; Earleywine and Barnwell, Harm Reduction Journal, 2007). This is a correlation from self-reports, not proof.

This survey was collected through email lists of drug law reform movements and was funded by the Marijuana Policy Project. In a small pilot study without a control group involving 20 people with respiratory symptoms, 12 were analyzed. After a month of using a vaporizer, they reported fewer symptoms (Van Dam and Earleywine, International Journal of Drug Policy, 2010).

Available reviews and commentaries assess vaporization of herb as probably less harmful to the respiratory system than smoking. However, the commentary by Loflin and Earleywine (Canadian Journal of Respiratory Therapy, 2015) notes the lack of long-term clinical studies; Earleywine is also a co-author of the survey and pilot study. An editorial by Chaiton et al. (Canadian Journal of Public Health, 2022) sees potential for harm reduction among those who already smoke regularly. It also reminds that new users may experience strong effects and cognitive disturbances regardless of the method.

All this pertains to herb. In 13 cannabis oil cartridges purchased in Washington state, metals from device components, including chromium, copper, and nickel, passed into the oil and vapor (McDaniel et al., Chemical Research in Toxicology, 2021). Cartridges also have their own history, described in the text about vitamin E acetate and the EVALI crisis. How a dry herb vaporizer differs from an e-cigarette is explained in the guide vaporizer: what is it.

Bong, joint or vaporizer: which is least harmful according to studies?

The vaporizer showed the least burdens in the collected measurements: lower carbon monoxide with similar THC in the blood (Abrams et al., 2007) and lower chances of respiratory symptoms in the survey (Earleywine and Barnwell, 2007). All smoking methods burn the herb; they also differ in the amount of data: for blunt and joint, there are measurements on humans, for bong one machine test, for pipe none. The table shows what was measured for each method.

Method What was measured Result Source
Joint vs tobacco cigarette carboxyhemoglobin and inhaled tar, 15 men about 5 times greater increase in carboxyhemoglobin, about 3 times more tar Wu et al., 1988
Cannabis smoke vs tobacco smoke composition of smoke from a smoking machine up to 20 times more ammonia, less PAHs in inhaled smoke Moir et al., 2008
Blunt vs joint carbon monoxide in exhaled air, 24 people higher after blunt Cooper and Haney, 2009
Cannabis with tobacco nicotine dependence criteria, 788 people more criteria when mixing weekly or daily Dugas et al., 2022
Bong and other water pipes vs joint tar per unit of cannabinoids, smoking machine all worse than joint, bong 30% more tar per unit of cannabinoids Gieringer, MAPS Bulletin, 1996 (not peer-reviewed, no gas measurements)
Pipe, bowl no separate measurement found in cohorts counted as joint Pletcher et al., 2012
Vaporizer Volcano vs cannabis cigarette THC in blood and carbon monoxide, 18 people similar THC, lower carbon monoxide Abrams et al., 2007
Vaporizer Volcano vs smoke compounds in vapor and smoke 3 compounds besides cannabinoids vs over 111 in smoke Gieringer et al., 2004
Vaporizer, survey reported respiratory symptoms, 6,883 people about 60% lower chances of symptoms (OR 0.40) Earleywine and Barnwell, 2007
Ingested cannabis time to onset of effects from 30 minutes to 2 hours, effects longer CDC, 2024

How to read these rows? They should not be compared numerically, as each study measured something different, on different raw materials and in different years. Measurements on humans in controlled conditions ranged from 15 to 24 people and pertained to short-term effects. For pipe and bowl, the table shows a gap, not a result. The least documented is the bong: its only test was not peer-reviewed and did not measure gases.

Do cannabis edibles bypass these risks?

They bypass the risk to the lungs but have their own. After ingestion, effects begin 30 minutes to 2 hours later and last longer than people expect (CDC, Cannabis and Poisoning, 2024). With inhalation, effects appear within minutes (Grotenhermen, Clinical Pharmacokinetics, 2003).

This difference explains the main risk of edible forms: it is easy to consume another dose before the first one takes effect. The CDC adds that the potency of THC in such products can be unknown or inconsistent with the label. In a Colorado hospital from 2014 to 2016, edible products accounted for 10.7% of cannabis-related ER visits, with 0.32% of sold THC (Monte et al., Annals of Internal Medicine, 2019). They were more often accompanied by acute psychiatric and cardiovascular symptoms. Edible forms are therefore not a milder version of smoking, but a different risk profile.

What is still unknown about the harm of these methods?

The most gaps concern the long term and methods other than joints. The longest data on lungs, 20 years in the CARDIA study and observation to age 45 in Dunedin, pertain to smoking. We did not find long-term clinical studies comparing the health of those who vaporize with those who smoke.

  • Bong: the only water test from 1996 was not peer-reviewed and did not measure gases.
  • Pipe and bowl: we did not find measurements of smoke from these devices; cohorts counted them as joints.
  • Vaporizer: symptom data come from a survey and a pilot study without a control group, and laboratory tests covered a few older models.
  • Lung cancer: large case-control studies and a smaller study from New Zealand yield different results.
  • Tobacco in the joint: carbon monoxide was measured for blunt, not for the joint with tobacco mix.

These gaps do not mean that all methods harm equally. They mean that the vaporizer’s advantage is based on short measurements and surveys, not on long-term observation. Popular beliefs about vaporization, compared with studies, are discussed in the text 10 myths about vaporizing herb.

The comparison pertains to health, not law: the Polish law on combating drug addiction recognizes as hemp plants in which the sum of THC and THCA in the tops does not exceed 0.3% dry weight (art. 4 point 5). Devices with temperature control can be found in the vaporizers category.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a vaporizer safer than a joint?

For the respiratory system, probably yes. In a study of 18 volunteers, vaporization resulted in similar THC levels in the blood with lower carbon monoxide than smoking (Abrams et al., 2007). A survey of 6,883 people was associated with lower chances of respiratory symptoms (Earleywine and Barnwell, 2007). We did not find long-term clinical studies.

Bong or joint: which is less harmful?

The data does not resolve this. In the only test of water pipes we found (Gieringer, MAPS Bulletin, 1996), the bong produced 30% more tar per unit of cannabinoids than a joint without a filter. The study was not peer-reviewed, and gases, including carbon monoxide, were not measured. Both methods burn the herb.

Does one joint harm like five cigarettes?

That number is an oversimplification. In a 1988 study (15 men), a cannabis joint produced about five times the increase in carboxyhemoglobin compared to a cigarette of similar weight and about three times more inhaled tar (Wu et al., New England Journal of Medicine). Participants inhaled deeper and longer, so the result is not a general conversion factor.

Does smoking cannabis cause lung cancer?

The evidence goes both ways. The largest case-control studies (Hashibe 2006; meta-analysis of six studies, Zhang 2015) found no clear link between cannabis smoking and lung cancer. A smaller study from New Zealand (79 patients, Aldington 2008) indicated an increased risk with long-term smoking. The matter is not settled.

Why is tobacco added to a joint?

One explanation comes from the laboratory: in a 2009 test, tobacco increased the efficiency of THC release from cannabis by up to 45% (Van der Kooy et al., 2009). This is a result from apparatus, not from human studies. In a cohort of 788 young adults, mixing was associated with more nicotine dependence criteria (Dugas et al., 2022).

How long does it take for ingested cannabis to take effect?

According to the CDC, the effects of ingested cannabis begin 30 minutes to 2 hours after consumption and last longer than people expect. The potency of THC in such products can be unknown or inconsistent with the label. Therefore, it is easy to consume another dose before the first one takes effect. After inhalation, effects appear within minutes (Grotenhermen, 2003).

This article is for informational and educational purposes and does not constitute medical advice. Before starting to use cannabis or CBD for therapeutic purposes, consult with a doctor, especially if you are taking other medications, are pregnant, or breastfeeding.

Author: Michał Waluk · Published: 2026-08-09 · Updated: 2026-10-27

Podziel się:
Zaufanie
Dowiedz się więcej o nas
Darmowa wysyłka
Od 49PLN - paczkomatem
Łatwy kontakt
Masz pytania? Skontaktuj się z nami.
Lojalność
Jedyny taki program - zbieraj buchy

Strona tylko dla osób pełnoletnich.

Czy masz ukończone 18 lat?

Buch z Tobą